Showing posts with label Obama. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Obama. Show all posts

Tuesday, October 6, 2009

Lawyers and Dentists and Birthers - oh my!

Today's Post has an article on a woman who is a big name in the birther movement. She's a lawyer, so she's represented some of the people who believe they should not have to be deployed because Obama's not a legitimate commander in chief. So far, her cases have been dismissed. Her core argument is that being a natural born citizen requires more than just being born in the U.S. It requires that one be born to two parents who are also U.S. citizens.

Also, she thinks Obama was born in Kenya, and his mother faked his Hawaii birth certificates. Naturally. Furthermore, she thinks that there are about 600 FEMA concentration camps where the government keeps dissident citizens.

And on the side, she's a dentist. (WTF?)

Friday, May 1, 2009

Clinton will not be on the SCOTUS!

I was appalled to see a post on a friend's Facebook page that she would be "pissed" if Obama appointed Bill Clinton to the Supreme Court to replace Souter. I think such a thing is VERY unlikely. There are many reasons for my thinking that it is unlikely. For example, I think Obama likely does not want a Clinton in a branch of the government he does not control.

However, the main reason I think it is INCREDIBLY unlikely that Obama will appoint Clinton is that Clinton was DISBARRED from the Supreme Court Bar. Come on people!

Tuesday, April 21, 2009

Disbar Bybee!

In the wake of the release of various torture memos, President Obama has stated he does not believe that the people who committed torture under the impression that they were legally allowed to do so should be prosecuted. I am not certain I agree with that thinking, but the question is: if we wanted to prosecute them, could we?

Certainly, anyone can prosecute them, but would we be able to put someone in jail for such behavior? In Cheek v. United States and Ratzlaf v. United States, the Supreme Court held that if you have an honest, good faith belief that you are not breaking the law, then you do not have the willful intent necessary to commit a crime. This ruling only applies to areas of the law that are complex, like tax law. However, one could say that CIA interrogation protocol is pretty complicated. If these people thought they were covered by the law, then they did not have the specific intent to commit the crime.

Generally, ignorance of the law is no excuse, but the Court did not want to punish a good faith misunderstanding of complex laws. Some courts point out that tax regulations, for example, are mala prohibitum (regulatory crimes like tax evasion) as opposed to mala in se (crimes that are evil by nature, like murder), so the ruling makes sense in all regulatory situations. In Staples v. United States, Justice Thomas stated that ignorance of the law can be an excuse, but it cannot be if you are dealing with, for example, a hazardous product that obviously would have regulations that you should have checked out. In the torture situation, it would be fairly evident to a CIA operative that interrogation techniques would be well-regulated, but if an operative had access to a letter from a DOJ attorney stating that waterboarding was okay, a non-lawyer could reasonably believe that such a memo was authority enough for what they are doing.

Some would argue that waterboarding is mala in se and that the operatives should have known that it was per se illegal. However, I think that the average CIA field operative probably participates in a lot of activities which would be considered mala in se illegal in my world, so their authority is not so clear cut.

The real problem lies with the lawyers, like Bybee, who drafted the memo. The torture memos show poor work by attorneys who quite obviously avoid any mention of cases which state that techniques like waterboarding are illegal. Bybee and his colleagues were telling the White House what it wanted to hear without regard to what the law actually said. I can certainly understand that one would want to provide the reasoning that helps the White House. However, no lawyer should be disregarding established law to the contrary of what he wants to prove. No one has said Bybee and his colleagues will definitely be prosecuted, but regardless, they should at least be disbarred.